Joint Communication from Five United Nations Special Rapporteurs to Italy Regarding Disciplinary Proceedings Against a Teacher and the Government’s Reply
Table of Contents
- Introduction
- The Allegations and the Mandates of the Special Rapporteurs
- Italy's Response
- Conclusion
Introduction
On 21 August 2026, UN Special Rapporteurs addressed Joint Communication AL ITA 3/2026 to the Italian Government and requested them to respond within 60 days.
The communication was submitted by a group of five Rapporteurs on the right to education; the right to freedom of opinion and expression; freedom of peaceful assembly and of association; human rights defenders; and the promotion of truth, justice, reparation, and guarantees of non-recurrence.
The communication concerns the Government’s actions regarding the implementation of a Ministerial circular of 7 November 2025 on schools, and the disciplinary measures taken against a secondary-school teacher, Ms Paola Fioravanti, following her class's participation in seminars on 3 and 10 December 2025. The seminars addressed the situation in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, and engaged with the work of a United Nations mandate holder. The reports received by the Ministry of Education and Merit triggered the dispatch of inspectors, leading to the teacher receiving a written reprimand from the school principal.
The UN experts lament that the episode could appear to constitute a disciplinary sanction inflicted on the teacher for cooperating with a UN Special Rapporteur, contrary to the State’s commitment to support the Special Procedures.
Italy’s Permanent Mission in Geneva responded on 20 October 2026, declaring that no person in Italy shall suffer any adverse measures due to cooperating with the United Nations’ representatives or its mechanisms. Therefore, the imposed restrictions on the teacher solely reflected the seminar’s compliance with the procedural rules concerning the involvement of an external speaker in the educational initiative and did not concern the identity and mandate of the speaker.
The Allegations and the Mandates of the Special Rapporteurs
An Italian literature teacher, Ms. Paola Fioravanti, may amount to acts of reprisal for engaging with, and facilitating the work of, Ms. Francesca Albanesea, a United Nations mandate holder, and for reinforcing awareness of international legal standards and the rule of law among students.
On 3 and 10 December 2025, in Pisa, Tuscany, Ms. Paola Fioravanti took part in an online presentation of the testimony book “When the World Sleeps” with many other schools across Italy, featured its writer, Ms. Francesca Albanese, Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights in the Palestinian territory. Ms. Albanese was invited by a group of teachers known as “Docenti per Gaza”, who are committed to disseminate information concerning the situation in the Occupied Palestinian Territories.
The teacher reportedly announced the initiative in advance through the school’s electronic register, as the official channel of communication within the institution. The event included the situation in Palestine among the topics that it aimed to address and it had been unanimously approved by the teaching staff at the beginning of the school year. It mainly aimed to explain the situation in the Occupied Palestinian Territory from the point of view of International law and it concluded with a question-and-answer session.
Local representatives of a political party, made the school subject of public statements by asserting on social media that the Special Rapporteur Ms. Albanese had described the Italian Government as “fascist” in an event with compelled participation via veiled threats. Reportedly, the participation in the event was carried out on a voluntary basis and these statements were not substantiated by any evidence. Therefore, the event was reportedly fully consistent with the school’s civic-education plan.
The Minister of Education and Merit, prompted by the social media post and a subsequent question submitted by a member of Parliament alleging that the event was managed in a manner not consistent with the Italian school regulations, entrusted the Regional School Office to dispatch inspectors. On 12 December 2025 the Regional School Office for Tuscany instructed technical inspectors (dirigenti tecnici) to verify and ascertain any possible liability.
The inspectors evaluated different aspects of the seminar, such as how the seminar had been organized, Ms. Albanese’s remarks, and the asserted absence of debate on the basis of a Ministerial circular of 7 November 2025. The Ministry of Education and Merit addressed this circular to school coordinators and invited them to guarantee the principles of pluralism, freedom of opinion, and critical thinking by including a confrontation between different positions.
Recalling that the Independant International Commission of Inquiry concluded in 2025 that Israeli authorities have been committing genocide against the Palestinians in Gaza, the UN Special Rapporteurs have expressed serious concerns regarding welcoming two sides, which could result in misrepresenting the weight of established findings, and contradicting the state’s responsibility of upholding victims’ rights. Moreover, they declared that it could be in odds with the right to academic freedom, and the right to promote, defend, and protect human rights, even where the speaker is a UN mandate holder bound by impartiality.
The Special Rapporteurs addressed another issue concerning the social media allegations and/or unverified political motives commencing inspection proceedings, claiming that it could have a chilling effect on others and discourage the discussion in schools on issues related to promotion, defense and protection of human rights.
Although inspectors found no irregularities, of approximately fifteen colleagues who participated in organizing the seminar, Ms. Fioravanti was the only one subjected to a disciplinary measure in the form of a formal reprimand from the school principal. Despite repeated requests, she received no further explanations for this targeted sanction and the Special Rapporteurs found the chilling effect it could have on others concerning.
These actions could improperly restrict rights to academic freedom, education, freedom of expression, peaceful assembly in schools, and the right to promote, defend and protect Human rights.
The Special Rapporteurs requested Italy to provide them with information regarding:
- The legal basis for the disciplinary measures and its compatibility of with the right to academic freedom,
- The safeguards to ensure that students are not subjected to disciplinary measures for addressing human rights issues, and the scope of the 7 November 2025 circular.
- The safeguards to ensure that the implementation of the above-mentioned circular does not result in misrepresenting the force of the judicial findings.
- The measures adopted to protect school staff from censorship when addressing highly politically charged issues.
- The measures taken to ensure the teacher’s access to effective remedy e.g; review of the disciplinary measure imposed on her, protection against any further reprisals.
- The steps taken to ensure the non-recurrence of such proceedings against teachers.
Italy’s Response
The Permanent Mission in Geneva on behalf of the Italian Government responded on 20 October 2026, exactly sixty days after the communication. They open by stating that no person in Italy is, or may be, subjected to any adverse measure for cooperating with the United Nations, its representatives or its mechanisms. Therefore, the measures taken were solely concerning the compliance with the procedural rules regarding the involvement of an external speaker in an event, and not the identity or the stance of the speaker; ergo, the freedom of expression remains unaffected. They cite the presidential Decree No. 62/2013 (code of conduct), Legislative Decree No. 165/2001(employees duty to comply with code of conduct) and No. 297/1994 (disciplinary sanctions for school staff) supporting the measures taken. Moreover, they clarified that the disciplinary measures taken against Ms. Fioravanti are consistent with the procedure ordinarily followed in respect of other teachers in similar circumstances.
The Italian Government presents the inspections carried out by the Regional School Offices as an ordinary routine (under the Decree No. 208/2023 article 8, and No. 185/2023), with independence and impartiality guaranteed by Ministerial Decree No. 21/2022. They have the sole purpose of verifying compliance with the procedures governing the school system.
Reportedly the inspectors identified several shortcomings in the organization of the meeting, pointing out that the event of this kind would have required a prior resolution of the Board of Teachers (Collegio dei Docenti), a prior resolution of the School Council (Consiglio di Istituto), the prior conclusion of an agreement with the promoting association, as well as the formal submission of the initiative to the Class Council (Consiglio di Classe).
Where an initiative includes an external speaker and participation of several classes during school hours, irrespective of the topic or the speaker, all components of the school community need to be in the position to assess its arrangements in advance.Therefore, the inclusion of the topic in the Civic Education plan approved at the beginning of the school year does not suffice.The inspectors revealed Ms. Fioravanti, as the sole promoter of the event, merely posted a notice in the electronic register, failing to submit it in advance to the school’s collegial bodies and to request the school head’s authorization.
Furthermore, based on the Ministerial circular of 7 November 2025 the absence of a counterpoint during the event breached the principle of pluralism. Her conduct was identified inconsistent with the minimum standards of diligence, providing the possible grounds for disciplinary liability.
The Italian Government declared the written reprimand does not affect the teacher’s remuneration or position, falling in the least severe sanction provided and in accordance with the principle of proportionality. Furthermore, the disciplinary proceedings against Ms. Fioravanti were conducted in full compliance with the Legislative Decree No. 165/2001 and No. 297/1994, guaranteeing the teacher’s right to defence. She had the opportunity to submit a written statement, take part in the defence hearing with the assistance of a lawyer or a trade union representative, or challenge the imposed sanction before the labour court. To this date, Ms. Fioravant has not lodged any appeal against the disciplinary measures.
The formal notice of the disciplinary sanction was served on Ms. Fioravanti on 8 January 2026 and a hearing was scheduled on 30 January 2026 for her to present her defence, followed by the decision dated 10 February 2026.
In the light of mentioned arguments, it can allegedly be concluded that there has been no violations of Ms. Fioravanti’s freedom of teaching, since she was a subject of sanction solely for having failed to comply with procedural rules of general application by not sharing the initiative with the collegial bodies and with the school head, and not because of the content of the initiative.
Conclusion
Italy’s response described a similar situation to the Special Rapporteurs' communication; however, there are multiple points of divergence, such as the irregularities found by the inspectors. It defended both the inspection and the reprimand under the domestic law and treated the existing law as sufficient, while leaving several factual allegations unanswered.
The Government based its response on a formal separation between the content and the procedure, but it failed to explain why the issue of the collegial approval arose only after the public controversy, exacerbating the Special Rapporteurs’ concern regarding the selective enforcement of a rule due to the content of the seminar. Moreover, Italy’s assertion that the procedure followed in respect of other teachers in similar circumstances is not supported by any examples.
Regarding the Special Rapporteurs’ concern about “two sides” in the debate, Italy did not mention the data confirming the genocide, offered no safeguard against misrepresenting the weight of the findings, and insisted that the circular creates no new obligations. Therefore, it supported the inspector’s action holding the teacher accountable for the absence of a counterpart on the basis of pluralism.
The communication mentioned how the absence of explanation and fear of retaliation could have a chilling effect on others. Italy in its response relied on the remedy depending on the individual’s initiative, emphasising that Ms. Fioravanti has not used the labour court or conciliation routes.
Documents
Keywords
How to cite this article
Melika Mohammadnejad (2026), "Joint Communication from Five United Nations Special Rapporteurs to Italy Regarding Disciplinary Proceedings Against a Teacher and the Government’s Reply", in Italian Yearbook of Human Rights, ISSN 3035-5435, http://unipd-centrodirittiumani.it/en/topics/joint-communication-from-five-united-nations-special-rapporteurs-to-italy-regarding-disciplinary-proceedings-against-a-teacher-and-the-governments-reply (consulted on 19/11/2026).