Gaza Strip

Break the selective silence on the genocide in Gaza

Article published on July 30,2025 on The Lancet, written by Roberto De Vogli, Jonathan Montomoli, Ghassan Abu-Sittah and Ilan Pappé.
A Palestinian searches through the rubble of his home destroyed by Israeli strikes in Khuza'a, southern Gaza Strip.
© UN Photo/Shareef Sarhan

De Vogli, R., Montomoli, J.,  Abu-Sittah, G. and Pappé, I. (2025) 'Break the selective silence on the genocide in Gaza', The Lancet

Substantial and well-documented evidence indicates a catastrophic public health emergency in Gaza (appendix pp 1–5), marked by severe food insecurity and alarming levels of malnutrition-related deaths.1 Life expectancy at birth reportedly declined by approximately 35 years in 2024.2 This represents a greater collapse in longevity than that recorded during the genocide in Rwanda, where life expectancy at birth declined from age 42·9 years in 1993 to age 12·2 years in 1994.3
Palestinian children have been disproportionately affected. Since October 7, 2023, Gaza has recorded more child deaths than any other conflict zone and has the highest number of children with amputations per person in the world.4 The health-care system has also been systematically dismantled. Between October, 2023 and May, 2025, there were 720 documented attacks on health-care targets, including 125 health facilities, 34 hospitals, and 186 ambulances.5 Gaza has recorded the highest numbers of health-care worker fatalities (over 1400 deaths), UN staff deaths (295 deaths), and journalist fatalities (212 deaths) in any recent conflict zone.6
Starvation is being used repeatedly and relentlessly as a weapon of war.7 Leading human rights organisations, UN agencies, and UN Special Rapporteurs have officially recognised the genocide in Gaza.8 This position is also supported by a broad and distinguished group of genocide scholars.9 However, most public health, medical, and social science associations have either remained silent or issued vague statements—a response that contrasts sharply with their rapid and vocal support in other conflicts, such as with Ukraine.10 This pattern suggests a selectively empathic response: a tendency to express solidarity with people who are perceived as being part of a so-called in-group and neglect those classified as an out-group based on nationality, ethnicity, religion, or geopolitical alignment.11
To challenge this selective silence, we issued an open letter urging professional and academic associations in the fields of health care, public health, and the social sciences to publicly recognise the genocide in Gaza and to revise their official positions accordingly (appendix pp 6–20).12 Within days, the letter gathered over 3300 signatures, including 1300 from academics and professionals. Moreover, the initiative prompted three major public health associations—the European Public Health Alliance, the European Public Health Associations, and the World Federation of Public Health Association, who represent over 5 million health professionals globally—to issue a joint statement acknowledging the genocide.13
The genocide in Gaza is a defining ethical test for the global public health community, social scientists, and academic associations. Silence is not an option. As scholars and health professionals, we face a stark choice: either we uphold our collective ethical responsibility and speak out to prevent further mass violence and starvation, or we will be remembered for our selective silence and inaction during one of the most urgent moral and public health crises of our time.


References

1. WHO, Malnutrition rates reach alarming levels in Gaza, WHO warns. WHO News Release, https://www.who.int/news/item/27-07-2025-malnutrition-rates-reach-alarming-levels-in-gaza--who-warns, Date: July 27, 2025, Date accessed: July 28, 2025, Google Scholar
2. Guillot, M ∙ Draidi, M ∙ Cetorelli, V ∙ et al., Life expectancy losses in the Gaza Strip during the period October 2023, to September 2024, Lancet. 2025; 405:478-485, Full Text, Full Text (PDF), Google Scholar
3. Our World in Data, Life expectancy at birth: Rwanda 1950–2023, https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/life-expectancy?tab=chart&country=~RWA, Date: 2025, Date accessed: July 11, 2025, Google Scholar
4. Bhutta, ZA ∙ Dominguez, GB ∙ Wise, PH, When is enough, enough? Humanitarian rights and protection for children in conflict settings must be revisited, BMJ. 2024; 386, e081515, PubMed, Google Scholar
5. Ferguson, S ∙ Su, T, Emergency response: UNICEF delivers wheelchairs for Gaza's children, https://www.unicefusa.org/stories/unicef-delivers-wheelchairs-gazas-children, Date: 2025, Date accessed: July 11, 2025, Google Scholar
6. WHO, Gaza Hostilities 2023/2024—Emergency Situation Reports https://www.emro.who.int/images/stories/Sitrep_59.pdf?ua=1, Date: 2025, Date accessed: July 11, 2025, Google Scholar
7. Ashour, Y ∙ Abu-Jlambo, A ∙ Abuzerr, S, Starvation as a weapon of war in Gaza: violation of international law, Lancet. 2025; 405, 2044, Full Text, Full Text (PDF), Scopus (0), Google Scholar
8. Amnesty International, Amnesty International investigation concludes Israel is committing genocide against Palestinians in Gaza https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2024/12/amnesty-international-concludes-israel-is-committing-genocide-against-palestinians-in-gaza/, Date: Dec 5, 2024, Date accessed: July 28, 2025, Google Scholar
9. Asem, S, Top genocide scholars unanimous that Israel is committing genocide in Gaza: Dutch investigation. Middle East Eye https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/top-genocide-scholars-unanimous-israel-committing-genocide-gaza-investigation-finds, Date: May 17, 2025, Date accessed: July 28, 2025, Google Scholar
10. American Public Health Association, American Public Health Association condemns invasion of Ukraine. APHA News Release https://www.apha.org/news-and-media/news-releases/apha-news-releases/2022/ukraine, Date: Feb 26, 2022, Date accessed: July 28, 2025, Google Scholar
11. De Vogli R. Selective empathy: the West through the gaze of Gaza. In: Studies in critical social sciences. Leiden: Brill (in press)., Google Scholar
12. De Vogli, R ∙ Montomoli, J ∙ Abu-Sittah, G ∙ et al., Stop the silence! Academic associations must recognise the genocide in Gaza. Open letter with 3,300 signatories. Change.org, https://www.change.org/p/stop-the-silence-academic-associations-must-recognise-the-genocide-in-gaza, Date: July 13 2025, Date accessed: July 28, 2025, Google Scholar
13. European Public Health Alliance, European Public Health Association, World Federation of Public Health Associations, Joint public health statement on Gaza https://epha.org/joint-public-health-statement-on-gaza/, Date: July 18, 2025, Date accessed: July 21, 2025, Google Scholar

Links

Keywords

Gaza Strip genocide, crimes against humanity health university research

Paths

Human Rights Centre